Free U.S. shipping on all print-on-demand products

Three Lives at the JTB Apartments: Kae’Lynn Matthews, Keonte Johnson, and Jaquann Mitchell

Three Lives at the JTB Apartments: Kae’Lynn Matthews, Keonte Johnson, and Jaquann Mitchell

On Saturday night, September 23, 2023, the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office responded to a shooting at the JTB Apartments, 8876 A C Skinner Pkwy, on Jacksonville’s Southside. It was around 10 p.m. In the parking lot and common area of the complex, four people had been shot. Three of them died.

They were Kae’Lynn Marie Matthews, 3 years old. Keonte Deshaun Johnson, 24. Jaquann Tarshon Mitchell, 23.

More than three years later, no one has ever been arrested in their murders. The case remains unsolved. A reward of up to $13,000 is still offered for information leading to an arrest.

This is what is known, stated exactly as the public record holds it.

The night

A group of five people had gone to the JTB Apartments in connection with a private dog transaction — possibly to buy or sell a dog, according to the Sheriff’s Office. A dispute broke out outside, and several shots were fired. Four of the five people in the group were struck. Three died. A fourth adult was shot and survived and was taken to a hospital. That person’s identity has not been made public.

A resident of the complex told News4JAX she heard “five or six gunshots” and screaming.

In the days after the shooting, the Sheriff’s Office said it was looking for two men seen leaving the scene in a dark-colored vehicle. In a renewed appeal in April 2025, the Sheriff’s Office said multiple suspects had opened fire on the group and fled in a black vehicle.

The Sheriff’s Office also said, in that April 2025 appeal, that Kae’Lynn’s mother had traveled to the apartment to meet the victims and drop off a dog, and that shortly after her arrival, the suspects opened fire. The Sheriff’s Office said a black Kia Optima was later found burned on Jacksonville’s Northside, and that evidence from the car linked it to multiple incidents across the city. That detail about the car comes only from the Sheriff’s Office’s April 2025 post; no news article was found repeating it.

The Sheriff’s Office did not release the victims’ relationships to one another, citing Marsy’s Law. In September 2023, Assistant Chief J.D. Stronko put it plainly: “We have just about as many questions regarding this incident as you do right now and it’s very early.”

The three who were killed

Kae’Lynn Marie Matthews was 3 years old. She was born the day after Valentine’s Day — February 15. Her family remembered her as a caring child who loved to dance and sing. Her visitation was held on Friday, October 6, 2023, from 5 to 7 p.m. at Funerals by T.S. Warden, and her memorial service the next morning, Saturday, October 7, at 11 a.m. at Westside Church of Christ. A GoFundMe was set up to help with her funeral expenses.

Keonte Deshaun Johnson was 24. Jaquann Tarshon Mitchell was 23. Both were killed in the same burst of gunfire, in the same parking lot, on the same night — and both, like Kae’Lynn, are still waiting for the person or people who shot them to be named.

That is the hardest fact in this case, and it is worth saying plainly: a 3-year-old child was killed in a dispute over a dog sale, in the parking lot of an apartment complex, in front of witnesses — and more than three years later, no one has been charged with doing it.

The reward

On October 3, 2023, the Florida Times-Union reported that a reward of up to $13,000 was offered for information leading to an arrest in this case — announced alongside the reward in the Mi’King Sims case, with donations from the Fraternal Order of Police Foundation. The Sheriff’s Office reaffirmed the reward in its April 2025 appeal.

The reward is still the standing offer. If you know anything about what happened at the JTB Apartments on September 23, 2023, contact the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office at 904-630-0500 or First Coast Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS (8477). Tips can also be texted to 8477, or emailed to JSOCrimeTips@jaxsheriff.org.

The lawsuits

On April 3, 2025, the families of all three victims announced three separate negligent-security wrongful-death lawsuits against the managers of the JTB Apartments, represented by the Haggard Law Firm and attorney Kimberly Wald. The lawsuits alleged inadequate security at the complex — lights not working, pool gates left open, open pedestrian access, and prior complaints ignored.

Kae’Lynn’s grandmother, Valencia Strowder, spoke publicly when the lawsuits were announced. She told Action News Jax: “We’re filing this lawsuit because we want to make sure this doesn’t happen to anybody else. If the managers at your apartment tell you you’re safe we want to make sure you can trust those words.”

The outcome of those lawsuits is not known. No settlement, dismissal, or verdict has been found in the public record as of this writing, and none is stated here.

What is not known

No suspect has been publicly named in these murders, and no arrest has been made. Beyond the Sheriff’s Office’s account — two men seen leaving in a dark-colored vehicle in September 2023, and multiple suspects fleeing in a black vehicle in the April 2025 appeal — no suspect descriptions have been released.

No motive has been established beyond the dispute that broke out during the dog transaction. Claims on social media that the dog sale was a cover for something else are speculation, and they are not repeated here.

The identity of the fourth person who was shot and survived has not been made public. Nothing beyond the Sheriff’s Office’s account is stated here about Kae’Lynn’s mother, and comments blaming her for bringing a toddler to the apartment are not repeated or engaged with.

What the record does hold is this: three people went to an apartment complex on a Saturday night in September 2023, and three people did not come home. A little girl who loved to dance and sing. Two young men, 23 and 24. A fourth person who lived, and whose name the public does not know. A parking lot on the Southside where five or six gunshots rang out and then went quiet.

Three years is a long time for a case to sit without an arrest. It is not too long for someone to speak. Cases like this one are solved by people who decide to talk — often about something small they did not think mattered at the time. A car leaving the complex that night. A conversation in the days after. A detail that seemed like nothing in September 2023 and only later becomes something.

If you know anything at all about the night of September 23, 2023, at the JTB Apartments — contact the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office at 904-630-0500 or First Coast Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS.

Justice has no expiration date.


0 responses to “Three Lives at the JTB Apartments: Kae’Lynn Matthews, Keonte Johnson, and Jaquann Mitchell”

Leave a Reply