Free U.S. shipping on all print-on-demand products

The Sleepover on Missouri Avenue: Megan Simmons and Jazmine Shelton

The Sleepover on Missouri Avenue: Megan Simmons and Jazmine Shelton

It was supposed to be an ordinary night between best friends. A sleepover at a trailer home on Missouri Avenue in Northwest Jacksonville — two girls, thirteen and fourteen, talking late the way best friends do. By 4:30 in the morning, it was a crime scene. More than twenty bullets had torn through the walls of the trailer, and both girls were dying.

That was Saturday, August 10, 2013. More than a decade later, no one has ever been arrested for it.

Two best friends

Megan Rene Simmons was fourteen years old. She was born April 19, 1999, in Jacksonville, and she was entering the eighth grade at Lakeshore Middle School when the new school year began. She wanted to attend college in Georgia and become a veterinarian. She liked swimming, horseback riding, and singing. Her obituary lists her mother as Kylie Jean Simmons, her father as Steve Chesire, and her stepfather as Jay Sightler.

Jazmine Destinie Shelton was thirteen. She was Megan’s best friend. The sleepover was at the home of Jazmine’s mother — the trailer on Missouri Avenue where the two girls spent that last night together.

They were not strangers to each other, and they were not strangers to the neighborhood. They were two girls at the start of their lives, doing what girls that age have always done: staying up too late at a friend’s house, certain that morning would come and the day would be ordinary.

The night of August 10, 2013

Around 4:30 on that Saturday morning, someone banged on the door of the trailer. Then the shooting started. More than twenty bullets struck the home. Police believe there were multiple shooters.

Jazmine Shelton died at the scene. Megan Simmons was rushed to UF Health Jacksonville, where she died four days later, on August 14, 2013.

Three other people were inside the trailer that night — Jazmine’s mother, her mother’s boyfriend, and another family member. All three were unharmed. The bullets found only the two girls.

Not the intended targets

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office has been clear about one thing from the beginning: the girls were not the intended targets. The shooting, investigators believe, was retaliation for a prior incident involving someone else in the trailer.

In 2024, Detective Travis Oliver of the JSO Cold Case Unit told Action News Jax that the case could be tied to a stabbing that happened a few hours earlier — a known person stabbed multiple times and being treated at a local hospital — and that one of the trailer’s occupants may have been involved in that earlier incident “in some capacity.” Oliver would not say who. The Sheriff’s Office has not named anyone in connection with the stabbing, and no suspect has ever been named in the shooting.

JSO has also cited a lack of cooperation from individuals who were at the scene as an obstacle in the case. That is the hardest sentence in this whole story to sit with. Two girls were killed in a house full of adults, and the people who might know what happened have not said enough to close it.

The long silence

The case was suspended in 2017. For seven years, it sat — unsolved, uncharged, waiting.

Around 2024, it was reopened. The Sheriff’s Office brought new forensic technology to the old evidence, reexamining the bullets recovered from the trailer, and featured the case as a JSO Cold Case Spotlight. The detective carrying it is Travis Oliver Sr., who was on the scene in 2013 and now works in the Cold Case Unit. He has carried this one for more than a decade.

Reopening a case is not the same as solving it. New technology can read old bullets differently. It cannot make witnesses talk, and it cannot name a shooter the evidence does not identify. As of the latest reporting, the case remains unsolved. No one has been arrested.

A grandmother who will not stop

Megan’s maternal grandmother, Karen Simmons, has been the public voice keeping this case alive. She spoke to News4JAX in 2019, six years after the shooting, and again to Action News Jax in May 2024. Her words in 2019 were plain and unadorned:

“I pray every day that some way we can find out who did it and put them where they need to be… I just want some peace, some closure.”

That is what a family asks for when the law has not yet answered: not vengeance, but a name, a charge, a reason. Peace and closure. A grandmother who has spent more than a decade praying for the same thing, and still waiting.

Megan was laid to rest after services on August 24, 2013, at the Paxon Revival Center Church, with interment at Riverside Memorial Park. She was fourteen. Jazmine was thirteen. Their names belong together in this story, because they were together that night, and because neither of them should ever be treated as a footnote to the other’s death.

What remains

The facts of this case are few and they are stark. Two girls, best friends, killed during a sleepover. More than twenty bullets. Multiple shooters, police believe. A retaliation that was not aimed at them. A case suspended, reopened, and still unsolved.

There is no suspect to name, because the Sheriff’s Office has named none. There is no motive to state as fact beyond what JSO has said it believes — that the girls were not the intended targets, and that the shooting was retaliation tied to someone else in that trailer. There is no reward amount to print, because none has been published for this case.

What there is: a case file that is still open, a detective who was there the night it happened and is still working it, a grandmother who still prays every day, and two names that Jacksonville should not forget.

If you know something about the night of August 10, 2013, on Missouri Avenue, contact the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office at 904-630-0500 or First Coast Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS. Crime Stoppers takes tips anonymously.

Megan Simmons was fourteen. Jazmine Shelton was thirteen. They went to a sleepover and never came home. Justice has no expiration date — and neither does the truth about what happened to them.

0 responses to “The Sleepover on Missouri Avenue: Megan Simmons and Jazmine Shelton”

Leave a Reply