Four Life Sentences: The Moncrief Triple Killing and the Gun That Talked Twice
On the night of February 8, 2021, officers near an apartment complex in Jacksonville’s Moncrief area heard more than 20 gunshots. A car sped away from the scene. When the chase ended, 17-year-old Owen Cosme was one of the passengers taken into custody. Inside one apartment, three people were dead.
That is the shape of the case: a planned robbery, a door knocked on, a volley of gunfire, and three lives ended in a matter of seconds. It took more than four years for the law to finish with it. When it did, Owen Cosme was sentenced to four life terms in Florida State Prison.
The night of February 8, 2021
Prosecutors said Cosme and others got a ride to the apartment complex to commit an armed robbery. Cosme, armed, knocked on an apartment door. When one of the victims opened it, he fired more than 20 rounds.
The three people killed inside were Sara Cancel Urriola, Randy Garcia, and Angel Rivera Nater. Their names matter more than his. They were the ones behind the door. They were the ones who did not survive the night.
Two others arrested in the case, Keon Lester and Kyshawn Glover, were both 18 when arrested. They pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree murder and robbery.
The gun that talked twice
What turned a triple homicide into a case with a second chapter was the ballistics. The .40-caliber casings recovered from the Moncrief apartment were matched through NIBIN — the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network — to an unsolved killing from July 23, 2020: a man shot more than 20 times outside his apartment.
The same gun, the same pattern, the same kind of violence, seven months apart. The 2020 victim’s name has not been established in the public record used for this account, and it is not stated here. What is established is the link: the casings from the Moncrief scene matched the gun used in the 2020 shooting, and that match connected Cosme to a second killing he had not been charged with at the time of his arrest.
Ballistics evidence does not argue. It does not forget. A gun leaves its signature on every casing it fires, and when the same signature showed up at two crime scenes, the two cases became one story.
The plea
On March 27, 2025, Cosme pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree murder for the 2021 triple killing, plus a separate count of second-degree murder for the 2020 shooting.
There was no trial. There was no jury. The guilty plea admitted what the evidence had already said: that he was the one who fired the shots at the Moncrief apartment door, and that the gun in his hands in February 2021 was the same gun used in the July 2020 killing.
Four years of waiting
Cosme was arrested on the night of the shooting, February 8, 2021. He was not sentenced until June 26, 2025 — more than four years later. That gap is the ordinary shape of a murder case working its way through the courts: charges filed, evidence tested, ballistics matched, negotiations held, a plea entered, a sentence imposed.
For the families of Sara Cancel Urriola, Randy Garcia, and Angel Rivera Nater, those four years were not ordinary. They were four years of waiting for a legal ending to a night that had already ended everything else. The guilty plea in March 2025 spared them a trial. The sentence in June 2025 gave them a final number: four life terms, plus 25 years.
There is no version of this story in which the sentence repairs what happened. A sentence does not bring anyone back. It does one thing only: it states, on the public record, what the law found and what it will do about it. The record now says that Owen Cosme killed three people in a Moncrief apartment on February 8, 2021, and a fourth person seven months earlier, and that he will spend the rest of his life in prison for it.
The sentence
On June 26, 2025, Judge Jeb Branham sentenced Cosme to four life terms in Florida State Prison, plus 25 years for the 2020 murder.
The Florida Department of Corrections record lays out the sentence count by count. For the February 8, 2021 offenses, Cosme received three life sentences for second-degree murder — one for each of the three people killed at the Moncrief apartment — and a fourth life sentence for burglary with assault. He also received 15 years for conspiracy to commit robbery with a firearm. For the July 23, 2020 offense, he received 25 years for second-degree murder. His Florida Department of Corrections number is Q92667. He is housed at Gulf Correctional Institution. His listed release date reads, simply: sentenced to life.
Four life sentences. Not one life for one act, but four — because the night of February 8, 2021 was not one act. It was a robbery planned, a door knocked on, and three people shot dead. And behind that night stood another night, seven months earlier, with another victim.
No legend. No legacy.
Owen Cosme was 17 years old when he fired those shots. He will spend the rest of his life in prison. There is nothing to admire in that, and nothing to mythologize. The No Legends series exists for exactly this reason: to refuse the story that a young man who kills three people is a legend, a folk hero, or a name worth repeating with awe.
The names worth repeating are Sara Cancel Urriola, Randy Garcia, and Angel Rivera Nater. They were the people behind the door. The gun spoke twice — once in July 2020, once in February 2021 — and the law, when it finally caught up, answered with four life sentences.
That is the whole of the story. There is no legend in it. There is no legacy. There are only three people who did not come home, and a fourth victim from a night seven months earlier, and a sentence that makes sure the man who fired the shots will never fire another.
Leave a Reply